Review prost facut de un jurnalist SAABului 9-5

Ce mai scrie presa despre Saab

Review prost facut de un jurnalist SAABului 9-5

Postby Edy » 27 Oct 2012, 08:34



Iata ca sunt jurnalisti de cea mai joasa speta si la americani. Jon Linkov de la Consumer Reports se ia urat de noul 9-5 subliniind niste "minusuri" fara sens, demonstrand nimic altceva decat ca uraste masina sau a fost platit sa faca un review atat de urat. Priviti numai cate zeci de comentarii sunt din partea oamenilor care au observat stupizenia lui Linkov, indiferent ca sunt sau nu fani SAAB!
Evident, nu pot sa scap ocazia sa aduc aminte din nou de valorosul nostru jurnalist roman Adrian Mitrea care a facut un lucru similar, oameni care nu au ce cauta in functia ce o ocupa.
Cititi cu atentie parerea oamenilor si adaugati-o si pe a dvs.!
SAAB 9-5 AERO, 2004, 2.3T 250cp, negru
SAAB 9-3 AERO, 2007, 2.8T Hirsch 275cp, negru
SAAB 9-3 AERO COUPE, 2002, 2.0T Maptun Stg3 270 cp, gri
SAAB 9-3 AERO COUPE, 2001, 2.0T 205 CP, negru
SAAB 9000 AERO, 1996, 2.0T 185 cp Italian Aero, albastru
SAAB 9000 Anniversary, 1997, 2.0T 150 cp, albastru
SAAB 900i SEDAN, 1987, 2.0i, 116 cp, verde
User avatar
Edy
Site Admin
 
Posts: 2567
Joined: 10 Dec 2004, 18:07
Location: bucuresti

Re: Review prost facut de un jurnalist SAABului 9-5

Postby Edy » 27 Oct 2012, 08:51

Cateva comentarii:
- "This must be the worst reviewer, that I've seen in the past 46 years! :-o"
- "hahahaha this guy just kill me trying to convince me that it is better to get a crappy Buick over Saab :))))))))))))) dude please go and check your mental condition ;)"
- "i am so sorry to say that such journalism is definitely not franc nor honest. This person was obviously out of line making a mokery of his profession. What happened to being factual and not judgemental. His whole performance on camera was very biast. Is he a BMW driver or maybe has he been told to shred every bit of the SAAB in every way. How much have you been paid to say all that? What a silly monkey!!!"
- "This guy is stupid. Why is he making reviews? This is a beautiful machine, why are you downing it?"
- "The roofpillars is got to be thick...So that the Saab is safer then your cheap American cars."
- "he's a dork. what can i do if you hit nightpanel button instead on ignition button. such a fool."
- "How good is the 9-5? The Aero's handling numbers at our test track bested the Audi A6 3.0 T, BMW 535i, Infiniti M37S and Mercedes-Benz E350 on the skid pad and beat all but the M37S in the slalom. Even then, the difference with the rough-riding Infiniti was a mere 0.4 mph. Edmundsdotcom"
- "I think journalism was about being neutral and objective ! By the way, when you title yourself as a "car journalist" you should perhaps learn a little bit of car's history. For instance, if the engine start/stop isn't placed in a normal way it is because of Saab's roots, not because they weren't smart enough to put it in the right place :) Comparing Saab to Buick, this is just a blasphemy. There is no comparaison to make ! No way, Saab is not a fake GM brand, sorry."
- "Comparing Saab with Buick? That Saab will still be driving around very much alive and kicking when all the Buicks of the same year will be on the scrap heap."
- "DId anyone else notice the he said it rode nice at and then in the same sentence said it was jittery? I think someone is got caught up in a lie..."

Oh, shit! :mrgreen:
SAAB 9-5 AERO, 2004, 2.3T 250cp, negru
SAAB 9-3 AERO, 2007, 2.8T Hirsch 275cp, negru
SAAB 9-3 AERO COUPE, 2002, 2.0T Maptun Stg3 270 cp, gri
SAAB 9-3 AERO COUPE, 2001, 2.0T 205 CP, negru
SAAB 9000 AERO, 1996, 2.0T 185 cp Italian Aero, albastru
SAAB 9000 Anniversary, 1997, 2.0T 150 cp, albastru
SAAB 900i SEDAN, 1987, 2.0i, 116 cp, verde
User avatar
Edy
Site Admin
 
Posts: 2567
Joined: 10 Dec 2004, 18:07
Location: bucuresti

Re: Review prost facut de un jurnalist SAABului 9-5

Postby bullet » 27 Oct 2012, 09:59

"There is no back-up camera, that's insulting in this price point"

Ca deh...nu mai putem parca daca nu avem camera de luat vederi in spate.
Image
User avatar
bullet
Saabist adevarat
 
Posts: 1293
Joined: 29 Jul 2008, 12:38
Location: Sibiu-Bucuresti

Re: Review prost facut de un jurnalist SAABului 9-5

Postby manolodsv » 27 Oct 2012, 10:15

un oligofren - care mai este placerea condusului ? fara camera nu se poate parca ? cauta ce nu are si americanul asta. :evil:
EX SAAB 9-3 SS 1.9 TID 120 cp - 2008 SAABinuta.
PRESENT SAAB 9-3 SS 2.0t Hirsch 210CP - 2008 Pa Pa Bum Bum.
User avatar
manolodsv
Saabist adevarat
 
Posts: 1995
Joined: 17 Feb 2012, 10:49
Location: Calarasi

Re: Review prost facut de un jurnalist SAABului 9-5

Postby MagicPenguin » 27 Oct 2012, 16:00

Mda... :x Nu are sens sa mai comentam prostia individului daca el are tendinta sa opreasca motorul de la butonul de NIGHTPANEL. Ca fapt divers Buick Regal (Opel Insignia) foloseste platforma Epsilon II SWB (short wheel base), iar 9-5-ul pe cea LWB (long wheel base) deci nu sunt chiar same shit, dar asta e o treaba prea tehnica pentru un critic de butoane. :roll:
Singurul aspect negativ cu care sunt de acord este faptul ca accesul in spate este greoi pentru persoanele inalte.
Pentru ca tot a venit vorba de A. Mitrea, trebuie sa recunoastem totusi ca video-ul review-ului pentru 9-5 este superb. :P
I drive:
Image
I miss:
Image
User avatar
MagicPenguin
Saabist adevarat
 
Posts: 2045
Joined: 26 Aug 2011, 09:16
Location: Bucuresti

Re: Review prost facut de un jurnalist SAABului 9-5

Postby Edy » 27 Oct 2012, 20:20

MagicPenguin wrote:Pentru ca tot a venit vorba de A. Mitrea, trebuie sa recunoastem totusi ca video-ul review-ului pentru 9-5 este superb. :P

Da, dar nu vorbeam de acela, saab-ul i-a placut desi e clar fan golf si bemve. Sa cautati sa urmariti ce spune despre bemveuri, mai-mai si ia la supt tzeava de esapament...
SAAB 9-5 AERO, 2004, 2.3T 250cp, negru
SAAB 9-3 AERO, 2007, 2.8T Hirsch 275cp, negru
SAAB 9-3 AERO COUPE, 2002, 2.0T Maptun Stg3 270 cp, gri
SAAB 9-3 AERO COUPE, 2001, 2.0T 205 CP, negru
SAAB 9000 AERO, 1996, 2.0T 185 cp Italian Aero, albastru
SAAB 9000 Anniversary, 1997, 2.0T 150 cp, albastru
SAAB 900i SEDAN, 1987, 2.0i, 116 cp, verde
User avatar
Edy
Site Admin
 
Posts: 2567
Joined: 10 Dec 2004, 18:07
Location: bucuresti

Re: Review prost facut de un jurnalist SAABului 9-5

Postby Edy » 28 Oct 2012, 16:01



Iata si un alt punct de vedere al altui american, dar de data asta ceva mai putin amenintator. Chiar daca versiunea testata nu era una de top (2.0t, 220 cai automat) el a recunoscut ca exista versiuni mai incitante pentru aceasta masina...care promitea multe atunci!
Una peste alta, mi-a placut acest review! " fell in love with the line of the car, it's a looker!"
SAAB 9-5 AERO, 2004, 2.3T 250cp, negru
SAAB 9-3 AERO, 2007, 2.8T Hirsch 275cp, negru
SAAB 9-3 AERO COUPE, 2002, 2.0T Maptun Stg3 270 cp, gri
SAAB 9-3 AERO COUPE, 2001, 2.0T 205 CP, negru
SAAB 9000 AERO, 1996, 2.0T 185 cp Italian Aero, albastru
SAAB 9000 Anniversary, 1997, 2.0T 150 cp, albastru
SAAB 900i SEDAN, 1987, 2.0i, 116 cp, verde
User avatar
Edy
Site Admin
 
Posts: 2567
Joined: 10 Dec 2004, 18:07
Location: bucuresti

Re: Review prost facut de un jurnalist SAABului 9-5

Postby Lixandru Razvan » 29 Oct 2012, 21:07

Primul review este de-a dreptul penibil si total pornit impotriva Saab-ului.Acest jurnalist parca are ceva personal cu Saab sau a fost pus, de scoate la iveala atatea inconveniente fara sens :evil: .Cine intelege si iubeste Saab -ul tot il va cumpara ,indiferent .Se leaga despre pretul ridicat al Saab-ului in comparatie cu ce iti ofera si competitia .Imi aduc aminte despre emisiunea facuta de catre cei de la Top Gear atunci cand Saab a intrat in faliment si la un moment dat James May spunea ca o rivala companie de automobile suedeze (banuiesc Volvo) nu intelegeau de ce un Saab este asa de scump pana cand au cumparat unul si l-au supus la teste de izbire :shock: :mrgreen: .A spus si ceva de genul cat reprezinta in procente din valoarea unui Saab dar nu am mai retinut ,oricum foarte interesant .Interesant si testul facut de Top Gear dintre Saab-ul 900 contra BMW -ului,atunci cand le-au dat drumul de la o anumita distanta pe plafon.BMW-ul s-a facut una cu pamantul pe cand Saab-ul s-a deformat un pic :mrgreen: .Spune-au ca nici nu mai era nevoie de cusca atunci cand concurau la raliuri asa de rezistente sunt caroseriile .

Cel de-al doilea review mi-a placut,mult mai corect :)
SAAB - Moves my mind
Lixandru Razvan
Senior
 
Posts: 174
Joined: 10 Sep 2011, 10:38
Location: Bucuresti

Re: Review prost facut de un jurnalist SAABului 9-5

Postby MagicPenguin » 29 Oct 2012, 21:11

Era o vreme cand se faceau masini, nu consumabilele din zilele noastre...

547061_453840331324748_1880740783_n.jpg
I drive:
Image
I miss:
Image
User avatar
MagicPenguin
Saabist adevarat
 
Posts: 2045
Joined: 26 Aug 2011, 09:16
Location: Bucuresti

Re: Review prost facut de un jurnalist SAABului 9-5

Postby Edy » 29 Oct 2012, 21:58

- "The roofpillars is got to be thick...So that the Saab is safer then your cheap American cars." :D
SAAB 9-5 AERO, 2004, 2.3T 250cp, negru
SAAB 9-3 AERO, 2007, 2.8T Hirsch 275cp, negru
SAAB 9-3 AERO COUPE, 2002, 2.0T Maptun Stg3 270 cp, gri
SAAB 9-3 AERO COUPE, 2001, 2.0T 205 CP, negru
SAAB 9000 AERO, 1996, 2.0T 185 cp Italian Aero, albastru
SAAB 9000 Anniversary, 1997, 2.0T 150 cp, albastru
SAAB 900i SEDAN, 1987, 2.0i, 116 cp, verde
User avatar
Edy
Site Admin
 
Posts: 2567
Joined: 10 Dec 2004, 18:07
Location: bucuresti

Re: Review prost facut de un jurnalist SAABului 9-5

Postby Lixandru Razvan » 30 Oct 2012, 12:33

Pentru mine in primul rand Saab inseamna siguranta si cred ca este cea mai importanta avand in vedere ce poate sa iti ofere o masina .Se spune ca cei de la Saab sunt obsedati de siguranta .
SAAB - Moves my mind
Lixandru Razvan
Senior
 
Posts: 174
Joined: 10 Sep 2011, 10:38
Location: Bucuresti


Return to Presa

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest